Blending Options>Bevel and Emboss



Blending Options>Stroke

 



Make a copy of the recently made layer and apply the same actions we did for the second layer of the very first puzzle. The layer’s color should be white.



The layer’s parameters: Fill 10%
Blending Options>Inner Glow

 



Make one more copy of the first puzzle’s layer and select Delete Anchior Point Tool to erase the unnecessary points. The Convert Point Tool will be helpful in making the necessary corrections on the element’s shape, making it look like in the next picture:



The layer’s parameters: Fill 15%
 Blending Options>Gradient Overlay



Gradient’s parameters:

 



Make one more copy of the first puzzle’s layer, applying the manipulations we did with the recently made layer, selecting also the same tools.



The layer’s parameters: Fill 11%



Finished!

View full size here.